logo

Published

Part 2

On the basis of a piece off Silverado, tell me about how the lyrics grew into their final form and what points of consideration were.

“Doing Alright” from Silverado was inspired by a real friend who has struggled with addiction.

We'd toured together, and there had been some very difficult times, as well as some hilarious ones. I tried to write from an imagined version of that person's point of view, thinking about the difference between how they might see themselves and how the world sees them.

The song arrived almost fully formed. I knew it was a risk to write about somebody I knew, especially about something so personal. Unexpectedly, that friend was at a show when I played it. They cried, and later sent me a very kind message.

It was a reminder that writing about real people carries a responsibility, even when you change the perspective and make the story your own.

Do you tend to start writing with what will be the first line of the finished lyrics? The chorus? At a random point? What are the words that set the process in motion?

It can start anywhere. I might write what I think is a verse and discover that it's actually the chorus, or the other way around. Sometimes it's a single phrase, sometimes a melody, sometimes a whole section.

I don't have a prescribed set of words that gets things moving, and I don't always know which part of the finished song I've written until much later.

I'd love to know how you think the meaning or effect of an individual song is enhanced, clarified or possibly contradicted by the EPs, or albums it is part of. Does the song, for example, need to be consistent with the larger whole?

With Silverado, there's definitely a theme running through the record. It's America seen through my eyes as a non-American. Some songs already existed and fitted that world naturally; others were written with the theme in mind.

“Come On” was written specifically for the album. I imagined the American musicians I've toured with as one person, trying to persuade their partner to give them a little longer to make a career in music work. They're away from home, the money is uncertain, and the person at home is carrying the burden.

After a gig, the character takes the long way home and sits outside the house, not quite able to face going in. There's even a darker moment when they take their hands off the steering wheel and close their eyes. I think they're chasing the intensity of being on stage, when the band and audience are together and it feels like the best drug in the world.

At the end, all the character wants is a stake in the ground for the two of them—an echo of the American frontier idea of building a future on your own piece of land. It's not really about fame. It's about wanting to make something lasting.

What I admire about the American musicians I've worked with is that they give the same commitment to fifty people as they would to fifty thousand. Showtime is showtime. I think a lot of British and European musicians could learn from that.

But I also wonder how much that work ethic is shaped by the absence of the welfare-state safety net we have in much of Europe. The pressure to keep working is greater when there's so much less to catch you if you fall. I'm not arguing that's a better society—I value public services and a welfare state enormously—but those pressures surely shape the musicians and the music.

That's part of the America I wanted Silverado to explore.

When you're writing song lyrics, do you sense or see a connection between your voice and the text? Does it need to feel and sound “good” or “right” to sing certain words? What's your perspective in this regard of singing someone else's songs versus your own?

I almost never do covers. I don't feel I can sing somebody else's words with the same truthfulness as my own. We did play Van Morrison's “Into the Mystic” once, and I found a way to make the words feel real to me. I think I got away with it, but I wouldn't necessarily try it again.

I sing in my own accent. I don't have a list of words I refuse to sing, but I probably avoid certain sounds instinctively because they would feel odd coming out of my mouth.

I'm very aware of the rhythm of language, almost in the way you think about metre in Shakespeare. When I listen back, I can hear when a line is clunky or doesn't sit properly with the rhyme or the rhythm. I'll change it or cut it. I don't want to settle for something that's merely okay.

I would love to know a little about the feedback you've received from listeners or critics about what they thought some of your songs are about – have there been “misunderstandings” or did you perhaps even gain new “insights?”

“L'Étranger”, from Gold on the Horizon, seems to connect with people in all sorts of ways. It's inspired by Albert Camus's novel, but you don't have to know the book to find something in the song.

I once played at a birthday party for a friend's elderly mother. She cried when I sang it and afterwards told me about growing up in the East End of London in the 1930s and 40s, and about how hard her life had been. She said it felt as though I was telling her story through the words. That was very humbling.

I hadn't written it about her, obviously, but she'd found something true to her own experience in it. Who am I to tell somebody that interpretation is wrong? I've also written about teachers, nurses and doctors, and people in those professions have come up after shows to say the songs resonated with them.

I don't often encounter complete misunderstandings. What interests me is how a song can become part of somebody else's life.

How do you know when a song is finished?

I suspect songs are never really finished until they go down on the record. Even then I might think of something else.

I've had to become a good editor because I often write too many verses and too many extensions, intros and outros. It took me a while to be comfortable cutting lines I thought were particularly good, but less is almost always more. If I can keep the essence of the song in fewer words, it's generally better music and a better story. And I can always bring an extra verse back into a live performance.

The title track of Silverado originally had extra verses and several different choruses, full of references to American culture. I was quite pleased with myself for writing them. But those ideas were already in the song, and I wanted the chorus to be recognisable and anthemic, something an audience could join in with.

So we kept one repeating chorus. It felt like a sacrifice, but the song became stronger. Sometimes editing is the most important part of finishing a song.

Creativity can reach many different corners of our lives. Do you feel as though writing song lyrics or poetry is inherently different from something like making a great cup of coffee? What do you express through music that you couldn't or wouldn't in more 'mundane' tasks?

For me, writing a song is fundamentally different from many everyday creative activities because it's unavoidably personal. I'm writing about myself, or my experience of other people and the world, and then standing on stage to sing it. Early on, that was nerve-racking. It takes time to stop worrying about whether everyone will understand.

Eventually I realised that the only critic I can really satisfy is myself. I have to be rigorous and honest about whether I've pushed the song as far as I can. If I have, I can live with somebody else not getting it.

You might paint a picture, hang it in a gallery and never see anybody react to it. My songs are meant to be performed. For me, making a record is ultimately about getting people to come to a show, whether it's just me or the whole band.

That live exchange matters enormously. I want to see the reaction, and hopefully people leave feeling something.


Previous page:
Part 1  
2 / 2
previous